Does a Non-Citizen Have Constitutional Rights?
Explore how the U.S. Constitution protects non-citizens and why these constitutional rights matter.
USCIS taking too long? Discover how a Mandamus lawsuit can get your case moving.
Get free and fast advice via WhatsApp for any questions you have!
Contact Us on WhatsAppIntroduction
The terms DACA vs Dreamers are often conflated, but they denote distinct statuses under U.S. immigration law. This guide unpacks the differences, history, and current state of DACA recipients and broader Dreamers, empowering you to stay informed and advocate effectively.
Key Takeaways
- DACA provides temporary relief and work authorization but no path to citizenship.
- “Dreamers” encompass all childhood arrivals, whether or not they hold DACA status.
- Renewal requires timely paperwork and fees every two years.
- Long-term security depends on future legislation like the DREAM Act.
What is DACA?
DACA vs Dreamers often gets mentioned together, but DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) specifically offers eligible undocumented youth deferred removal and employment authorization, renewed biennially.
Protection from Deportation
Shielded from removal while DACA is active.
Work Authorization
Eligible to apply for an Employment Authorization Document.
Who Are the Dreamers?
“Dreamers” refers to all undocumented individuals brought to the U.S. as minors under proposals like the DREAM Act—even those without DACA status. They face varied legal uncertainties.
- Arrived before age 16, often too young to decide migration.
- Some hold DACA; others lack formal protections.
- Contribute socially and economically despite ongoing risks.
Legal Status of DACA Recipients vs Dreamers
The key distinction lies in formal protections: DACA grants deferred action and a work permit, whereas other Dreamers may have no authorized status.
Eligibility Requirements
- Age Requirement: Applicants must be under the age of 31 as of June 15, 2012. This means that individuals who were born on or after June 16, 1981, are eligible to apply.
- Entry into the U.S.: To qualify, individuals must have entered the United States before reaching their 16th birthday. This requirement ensures that applicants have established ties to the country from a young age.
- Continuous Residence: Applicants must demonstrate continuous residence in the U.S. since June 15, 2007. This means they should not have left the country for extended periods during this timeframe.
- Educational Attainment: Eligible individuals must be currently enrolled in school, have graduated from high school, or possess a General Educational Development (GED) certificate. This requirement emphasizes the importance of education in the eligibility criteria.
- Criminal History: Applicants must not have a serious criminal history. This typically means that individuals should not have been convicted of felonies or significant misdemeanors that could impact their eligibility.
Understanding these eligibility requirements is crucial for potential applicants. Meeting these criteria not only opens the door to various immigration benefits but also ensures that individuals are prepared for the responsibilities that come with legal residency. It is advisable for applicants to gather all necessary documentation that supports their claims regarding age, residency, educational status, and criminal history before submitting their applications.
Additionally, potential applicants should stay informed about any changes to immigration policies that may affect these requirements. Consulting with an immigration attorney can provide valuable insights and guidance throughout the application process, helping to navigate any complexities that may arise.
Benefits and Limitations
Benefits
- Legal Employment Eligibility: Individuals with this status can legally work in the United States, providing them with opportunities to gain valuable work experience and contribute to the economy.
- Protection from Deportation: This status offers a shield against deportation, allowing individuals to live without the constant fear of being removed from the country.
- Access to In-State Tuition and Scholarships: Eligible individuals can benefit from reduced tuition rates at public colleges and universities, as well as access to various scholarships that are not available to out-of-state residents.
- Ability to Obtain Driver’s License: Many states allow individuals with this status to apply for a driver’s license, facilitating mobility and independence.
- Opportunity for Community Engagement: With legal status, individuals can participate more fully in their communities, including volunteering and engaging in civic activities.
Challenges
- Temporary Status with Frequent Renewals: The status is not permanent and must be renewed every two years, which can be a cumbersome process requiring documentation and fees.
- No Direct Path to Citizenship: While this status provides some benefits, it does not offer a straightforward route to permanent residency or citizenship, leaving individuals in a state of uncertainty.
- Vulnerability to Political Changes: The status can be affected by shifts in political climate and policies, which may lead to changes in eligibility or benefits, creating instability for those relying on it.
- Limited Access to Federal Financial Aid: Individuals with this status may not qualify for federal financial aid programs, making it more challenging to finance higher education.
- Potential for Increased Scrutiny: Those with this status may face additional scrutiny from law enforcement or immigration authorities, leading to anxiety and fear within their communities.
The DACA Renewal Process
- Submit Form I-821D (“Consideration of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals”).
- Submit Form I-765 (Employment Authorization Application).
- Pay $495 fee (check USCIS for updates).
- Provide proof of identity, residence, and prior DACA approval.
- Undergo USCIS background check.
Current Legal Challenges
- 2017 Rescission Attempt: The Trump administration’s attempt to rescind the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program faced significant legal hurdles, ultimately being blocked by various courts. This effort raised critical questions about executive power and the rights of undocumented immigrants who had relied on DACA for protection from deportation.
- 2018 Ninth Circuit Stay: In a pivotal ruling, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a stay that allowed DACA renewals to continue during ongoing litigation. This decision underscored the importance of judicial oversight in immigration policy and provided temporary relief to thousands of DACA recipients who were at risk of losing their status.
- 2020 Supreme Court Ruling: The U.S. Supreme Court delivered a landmark decision in June 2020, ruling against the Trump administration’s attempt to terminate DACA. The Court found that the administration had failed to follow proper procedural guidelines, highlighting the significance of due process in immigration matters. This ruling not only preserved DACA for the time being but also set a precedent for how future administrations might approach similar immigration policies.
What Does the Future Hold?
- DREAM Act: The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act aims to provide a pathway to permanent residency for qualifying Dreamers—young individuals who were brought to the United States as children. This legislation seeks to recognize their contributions to society and allow them to fully participate in the American dream.
- American Dream & Promise Act: This comprehensive piece of legislation not only extends protections to Dreamers but also includes provisions for Temporary Protected Status (TPS) and Deferred Enforced Departure (DED) holders. By offering broader relief, the American Dream & Promise Act addresses the needs of a diverse group of immigrants who have established their lives in the U.S. and are seeking stability and security.
- Bipartisan Support: Achieving durable immigration reform hinges on bipartisan support. For any proposed legislation to gain traction and ultimately be enacted, it is crucial that lawmakers from both major political parties come together to find common ground. This collaboration is essential for creating a sustainable and effective immigration policy that reflects the values and needs of the American populace.
As we look to the future, the potential for immigration reform remains a topic of significant discussion and debate. The success of initiatives like the DREAM Act and the American Dream & Promise Act will depend not only on legislative action but also on public support and advocacy efforts. Engaging communities, raising awareness, and fostering dialogue around these issues will be vital in shaping a more inclusive and equitable immigration system.
In conclusion, the future of immigration policy in the United States is uncertain but filled with possibilities. With the right combination of legislative efforts, public support, and bipartisan cooperation, we can hope for a future that honors the contributions of all immigrants and provides them with the opportunities they deserve.
Conclusion
Understanding DACA vs Dreamers is vital to informed advocacy. While DACA offers temporary protections, a lasting solution requires legislative action for permanent status.
If you or someone you know is navigating immigration issues, call us at (212) 566-3572 or contact our legal team.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What does DACA stand for?
Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals—temporary deportation relief & work permit.
2. Who qualifies as a Dreamer?
Undocumented individuals brought to the U.S. as children, regardless of DACA status.
3. Can DACA recipients become U.S. citizens?
No; DACA does not confer a path to citizenship.
4. How often must DACA be renewed?
Every two years.
5. What if DACA is terminated?
Recipients lose work authorization and deportation protection.
6. Are Dreamers eligible for federal financial aid?
No; they may qualify for state aid or private scholarships.
7. Can DACA recipients travel abroad?
Only with advance parole for approved reasons.
8. Difference between DACA and DREAM Act?
DACA is an executive program; the DREAM Act is proposed legislation offering a path to citizenship.
9. How many Dreamers are in the U.S.?
Approximately 1.7 million, with ~700,000 DACA holders.
10. Primary challenge for Dreamers?
Lack of a permanent residency path creates ongoing uncertainty.
Get complimentary general advice via email or WhatsApp!
For more in-depth legal counsel, phone or office consultations are available for a flat fee for up to 40 minutes.
Contact Us on WhatsApp Visit Our Contact Page